Home Life & CultureLifestyle The Real Stats and Facts of The Guardian’s Poor Abruzzo

The Real Stats and Facts of The Guardian’s Poor Abruzzo

by Sam Dunham
ferrari tractor Baascianella

Last week The Guardian printed a travel article about skiing in Abruzzo, fantastic for getting a journalist out beyond the Alps and profiling Abruzzo as a good place to , but its introduction defining ‘Abruzzo one of Italy’s poorest regions’ triggered tremors of consternation amongst many in Abruzzo and those around the world who know & love the region.  It prompted many to wonder where the stats were to support such a statement and what was the context of ‘poorest region’? It certainly does not seem consistent with what anyone who knows the region would recognise as present-day Abruzzo.

Eurostats is the official body in the EU whose role it is to provide comparative stats across the EU nations; their last handbook for data gathered in 2005 was published in 2009. In this guide Abruzzo ranks as number 14 in the 21 Italian regions with a GDP of €20,600, which is 83% per capita of the national average according to the Banca Italia.  From these published figures Abruzzo scores higher than Sardinia whose GDP per capita sits at €19,300, at the bottom, the ‘poorest’ is Sicily, where the GDP per capita is €16,200. Just as a reference point the average GDP per capita within the EU is €21,503.

It is an undisputed historical fact that Abruzzo was indeed one of Italy’s poorest regions in the past; cut off by its mountains, controlled by the Kingdom of the 2 Sicilies, its residents’ “poverty” resulting  in multiple diasporas of hard-working Abruzzesi to Switzerland, Scotland, Canada ,the US and Australia, to name but a few.  But that is the past…

By 1997, out of the 44 regions across the EU that had applied & received EU supplementary funding under the auspices of Objective 1 in 1989, including the likes of Lisbon, Abruzzo was the first and only region whose economic growth & output saw it surpass the lower limits of what the EU deemed a region requiring financial assistance, as it expanded its economy from just agriculture to industry & tourism.  The other regions still struggled and, up to when the scheme was withdrawn in 2006, all remained receiving additional help from the EU.

As in everywhere in the world, if you look hard enough you will find disparity in wealth and perhaps the extreme forms of it with poverty all too ubiquitous throughout Europe.  Living in Hackney, London, where the gap between the middle classes, the rich and the tower block kitchen sink estates where people really do live in poverty, we see this all the time.  Local children were recently given cameras to therapeutically record their daily lives as part of an exhibition at the local Childhood Museum. The Olympic Council awarded London the 2012 Olympics in its plan to help rejuvenate this as part of a ‘deprived’ area.  As far as I am aware no such honours or therapy is ongoing in Abruzzo.

Much like the author of The Guardian piece, I should not make out-of-context statements, comparing my straddling of a rural life in Abruzzo to that of living in metropolis London, it is after all like comparing oil & water; instead I am going to end on the richness & little luxuries that life in Abruzzo brings which focus on not just its GDP but the lifestyle that the region offers; as Ghandi questioned “Does increasing the speed of life improve our quality of life?”

Abruzzo Luxuries:

  1. The ability to buy delicious paper-wrapped bread in quantities I need rather than having to buy a whole loaf in plastic and throw away the unused is a luxury, and for the eco-conscious such a luxury would help reduce the UK’s household national waste of 8.3 million tonnes per annum.
  2. As a dog owner to be able to my spaniel freely without a worry of a pit bull terrier or ‘staffy’ tearing into it, which, has happened on more than one occasion and makes walking a dog a terrifying experience rather than one of joy!
  3. The water!  Water that doesn’t just taste great but which requires the smallest amount of shampoos and washing liquid is wonderful, not just for human consumption but what in effect sewage plants need to deal with as part of our environmental footprint.
  4. The quality of the air!  The acidic smell on return to a large metropolis after being in Abruzzo has to be smelt to be believed… this is something that we shouldn’t just get used to…
  5. Incredible food which allows you to eat out and enjoy a scrumptious 3-course meal with wine for 2 for under €30, and which subsequently results in many families being able to eat out together once a week even if that is just .
  6. Council tax!  What it costs for 1 year in Abruzzo, is less than 2 months in Hackney whose council receive Formula Grant to help keep the borough’s council tax lower than average in London. My council tax in Abruzzo even contributes to my very small village in Abruzzo having Christmas lights up in the street, I can’t say the same of Homerton.
  7. Vegetables & fruit that smell and taste like they should.  My organic veggie pick up never ever tastes like the fruit& vegetables that I buy or eat in Abruzzo.  If I buy garlic from a supermarket in England it doesn’t even smell; how wrong is that?!
  8. The compassion of the Abruzzo people.  Beyond the usual cheeriness, it sometimes seems, of simply being ‘Italian’, the people I have encountered and now call my friends are some of the most compassionate and generous people that I have met in my life.
  9. Again as a dog owner, the ability to walk the streets without having to avoid the spat out chicken bones that fast fried chicken living brings to children and adults who don’t sit and eat together but snack.
  10. Community; people care. If I was to be old, ill and alone anywhere it wouldn’t be the UK where I chose to live & die, worried that I could be in my flat for weeks before being discovered.
  11. Togetherness.  People make time to sit and eat together whenever possible to share the day, celebrating the joys and listen to the problems.The family unit is still a very strong component of society, often in an extended form, with children, parents, grandparents, and at times even great grandparents living close by. The elderly in most cases are held in high regards and are often quite involved in the moral and social upbringing of children.
  12. Space – There is a huge amount to explore & revel in -a density of just 123.5/km2 (319.7/sq mi) compared to London’s 12,331/sq mi (4,761/km2).
  13. Teenagers that don’t get drunk & mashed in ‘gangs’, and end up feral & aggressive as they roam the streets.
  14. The most spectacular, uplifting scenery, whether in the mountains or along it’s miles and miles of gorgeous .
  15. A crystal clear, warm Adriatic Sea with many beaches awarded the EU Blue Flag Status to enjoy in the summer months.

Top 10 Posts by Italy tutto


james and debbie Els 21/02/2010 - 19:40

Couldnt agree more with your informative appraisal of abruzzo and the qualities of the people and the region. Your readers comments spot on – its the perfect antidote to the stressors and pressures of life in the UK.

Leor Barnett 06/02/2010 - 15:31

In response to this article, I must say that When I visited Abruzzo with my boyfriend last summer, one thing that did not stand out was poverty (which is a bit surprising considering “its One of Italy’s poorest regions” according to the Guardian writer). What did however stand out was a deeply rooted culture that has been carefully preserved. Yes, it is very different to what we are used to, it is a more basic lifestyle, but since when does basic = poverty? In fact, I felt it was on the contrary. This basic life represented for me a sort of richness and quality of life(I know I’m talking now from a different perspective and not in financial terms) but I’m envious of their attitude. I wish I were able to go back to a point where I could think in more purer terms about what is important in life and take example from these people whose priorities, mentality and sense of community are what has led to the preservation of their culture.

I would assume that with The Guardian writer's tight deadlines and busy schedule, he barely got the opportunity to visit most places in Abruzzo. After all, it was an article focused on its skiing resort, directed at the Middle class readers. Perhaps his skiing goggles prevented him from seeing the truth of it all.

Comments are closed.

All about Abruzzo in a slow travel & food blog
All about Abruzzo in a slow travel & food blog